If they both die to fallout, and both get devoured, wouldn’t you want the larger of the two creatures? It makes sense to me that having a 2/2 on the board provides greater utility than a 1/1; if only because of blocking tricks. (Civic can trade with a bloodbraid elf, and other 2/2s)

ME (life 14): Cloudthresher (that ate a Broodmate Dragon during his last attack), Chameleon Colossus, Treetop Village, and some lands.
OPPONENT (life 12): Broodmate Dragon (no token), Civic Wayfinder, Treetop Village, and lands.

So it’s my turn after his Broodmate swung into my Thresher and I swing with Cloudthresher and Colossus and he blocks the Thresher with Wayfinder and takes the Colossus hit. I opt not to pump and he goes to eight. I proceed to lay a Broodmate Dragon and ship the turn. He then untaps (8 mana total), and casts Primal Command with modes gain seven and search. This puts him to fifteen life, and he searches out Karrthus. I know that I can’t kill him through the Broodmate and possibly activated Treetop he has on his side, and I am dead to the Karrthus/2X Broodmate/Broodmate Token/Colossus against my Thresher and Treetop unless I can pull some shenanigans.

On my turn I draw a Kitchen Finks and that has the ability to put me to enough life to allow me to all-in him here with everything and force him to sacrifice his Treetop chumping the Colossus, and Broodmate Dragon in front of the Cloudthresher. I’m not positive if this attack is correct in retrospective as leaving back the Cloudthresher gives me a way of trading with Karrthus when he would swing, with the drawback being he has an extra 4/4 in the air. Still, the play I made was going all in there, and then playing Finks going to sixteen. He is on four life after the attack (Broodmate+Token+Treetop did eleven there).

He realizes the Karrthus play is now not lethal, and plays it, but decides to swing with only Karrthus and Broodmate Token of mine that he stole. This puts me to five life, and he has an untapped Colossus and Broodmate Dragon on his side. I untap for my turn and draw PRIMAL COMMAND (YAUS!). I have an untapped Cloudthresher, untapped Finks, and Treetop with eight mana available total. I play Command for the same modes he did (gain seven and search……for Karrthu), and pass the turn now at twelve life. He decides to attack with everything (knowing very well what is going to happen next turn), with my Cloudthresher blocking the Karrthus, and Finks blocking the Colossus, and Broodmate Dragon and token getting in for eight in the air. I go to four, and then six with Finks’ trigger. He has no Banefire, and next I get to return the Dragons to their rightful owner.

Game three he struggles quite a bit with his mana, and I have an excellent draw to capitalize on it (turn four Broodmate, turn 5 Cloudthresher).

So, we had a Karrthus on Karrthus battle, which is something that you won’t hear about too often very likely.

Worst memorable game, i ramp up to 5 mana with the 6th in my hand and 2 broodmate dragons, he plays his maindeck Thought Hemorrhage naming Broodmate Dragon.

Good report, though.

Also, is Cabrera a joke? I don’t think he understands the deck at all.

good write up Mike. I really like the deck and i guess if we both played a bit better things would a went a bit better. o well i guess there is always next time.